Longitudinal outcomes of post-traumatic stress disorder among the Indian Ocean tsunami survivors in Indonesia
Jumat, 14-10-2022Ni Wayan Suriastini, Bondan Sikoki, Cecep Sumantri, Rodhiah Umaroh
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) following a disaster could change over time. This study aimed to analyze the risk factors of PTSD among the 2004 Indian tsunami survivors in Aceh and North Sumatra province, Indonesia. It mapped the trajectory recovery pattern of mental illness and examined the medium-term PTSD consequence five and 18 months after the disaster using a large longitudinal survey. Multivariate logistic regression was employed to derive the association between the post-traumatic stress disorder trajectory group and risk factors. The results showed that 15% and 20% of the respondents had persistent medium-term and delayed-onset PTSD, respectively. The vital predictors of persistent PTSD included being female, aged 50 and older, married, and having higher direct trauma exposures to the tsunami. Furthermore, delayed-onset PTSD was associated with negative life events after the tsunami and perceived less social support. The results indicate the necessity to understand the predictors for each PTSD trajectory group's effective intervention regarding mental health after the disaster.
In the early morning of December 26, 2004, a great 9.1 magnitude earthquake hit the Indian Ocean, causing the most devastating tsunami of this century. The tsunami spread to the large surrounding areas, including Southeast and South Asia and East Africa , leaving approximately 280,000 people dead and more than 2 million displaced from their homes . Indonesia's Aceh and North Sumatra provinces were the most struck by the tsunami that covered 413 km2 . Moreover, the deadly disaster caused an almost 24% drop in Aceh's population . Nearly 150,000 people were killed, more than 20,000 were injured, and 200,000 buildings collapsed, including houses, hospitals, schools, bridges, and roads [2,3].
This catastrophe tragedy left victims in despair and shock after losing their homes and family members, being displaced, and living with uncertainty. The sudden losses took their toll in the form of traumatic feelings and psychological distress . Previous empirical studies had assessed the impact of natural disasters on victims' mental health. The results showed that people suffering from such events were more likely to develop mental illnesses, such as depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) [, , ]. Unfortunately, mental illness among survivors is prolonged because its symptoms are detected after five to ten years or even longer the following disaster [7,, , ].
Survivor-focused disaster studies generally inspect the symptoms of post-disaster psychological distress by estimating the risk factors associated with mental illness. However, recent studies have begun considering recovery patterns to overcome the limitation of only discussing the mental disorder symptoms [, , ]. They focused on post-disaster outcomes, including adaptive and maladaptive cases, by viewing the trajectory recovery patterns . Studies on the longitudinal effect of post-traumatic stress disorder and depressive symptomatology indicated that around 7%–58% of survivors recovered from PTSD symptoms in 4–5.5 years. In contrast, 6%–26% remained persistent with the symptoms. The case for the delayed breakdown, with symptoms appearing six months or longer following the traumatic incident, was estimated to be between 4% and 19% [9,13,16].
The development of different outcomes of post-disaster PTSD could be rendered by trauma related to the disaster, adverse life events, and lack of support system. The job loss and drop in subjective economic status caused the maladaptive cases in Japan five years after the tsunami and the 2011 great earthquake . Similarly, negative life events, including divorce, death, and workplace problems, increased delayed PTSD cases among the WTC attack survivors in the United States . Three years after the Katrina Hurricane in 2005, the victims experienced more persistent PTSD than those concerned about their parents and relatives. This indicated that the support system from close family or friends is critical to remit the symptoms and the disaster's negative effects [14,17,18]. Perceived family support significantly assists adolescent survivors of the earthquake in Turkey cope with long-term psychological distress more than tangible support for 9/11 survivors [19,20]. Additionally, social support was a protective factor against delayed-onset PTSD among the Wenchuan Earthquake survivors in China .
Many studies have documented the long-term impact of the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami on mental health, with a varied prevalence of post-traumatic stress disorder. 9-month surveillance reported 12% of PTSD displaced survivors in Thailand . In Sri Lanka, the investigation found 56% PTSD prevalence among the displaced people six months after the tsunami, with females facing a double risk that has remained five years later [22,23]. PTSD was 12.7% among survivors aged 18 and older in India two months after the disaster and a higher rate for those injured during the tsunami . Furthermore, 36.5% of the Norwegians tourist in Khao Lak, Thailand, experienced post-traumatic stress disorder two and half years after the disaster . An assessment among respondents aged 15 and older found a higher PTSD score for those living in heavily damaged than moderately and undamaged areas five months after the tsunami in Sumatra, Indonesia .
The analysis of the PTSD trajectory recovery pattern of the survivors' mental health in the medium-term remains unclear and limited despite the findings. Understanding the pattern helps clinicians and health care practitioners provide better long-term mental health interventions after the disaster. Earlier detection and prevention could help survivors reduce persistent mental health, prevent the late-onset of psychological distress, and escalate the recovery rates. Therefore, this study aimed to analyze the risk factors of PTSD among Indian Ocean tsunami survivors in Aceh and North Sumatera provinces. It also mapped the post-traumatic stress disorder trajectory pattern of mental illness using a large survey sample in Indonesia. The study examined the medium-term consequence of mental disorders five and 18 months after the disaster. Additionally, it examined demographic characteristics, trauma exposures, counseling support, and negative life events experienced by victims to predict PTSD.
Data were obtained from the two first waves of Tsunami Aftermath and Recovery (STAR). The STAR was a longitudinal survey designed using the original frame from a population-representative national socio-economic survey (SUSENAS) collected by the Indonesian Bureau of Statistics. The first and second STAR was conducted in May 2005 and June 2006, five and 18 months after the tsunami, respectively. This survey collected detailed information on experiences during the tsunami from respondents using
The statistical description of respondents' characteristics
The mean age of respondents was 35 years, ranging from 15 to 99. The likelihood of female and male respondents meeting the inclusion criteria and completing the survey was 56% and 44%, respectively. Based on age, 37% of respondents were elementary graduates, 65% were married when the tsunami occurred, and 59% lived in medium-damaged areas. Moreover, 65% of respondents owned private houses, and 26% had a house near a river, lake, or sea. The average PCL score was 12.3 at wave 1 and decreased to
PTSD prevalence among the 2004 Indian ocean tsunami survivors in Aceh and North Sumatera Provinces, Indonesia, remained high. There was a slight decrease from 38% five months after the tsunami to 34% 18 months after the following disaster. The magnitude of reduction of symptoms could differ depending on the extent of damage, time length post-disaster, and the type of disaster. This study showed only a 4% reduction in PTSD, while Payayong et al. found a 41% drop three years after the same
Post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms continue to affect the Indian ocean tsunami survivors in Indonesia five and 18 months after the following disaster. The results showed that 15% of the respondents developed persistent PTSD until the last survey, while 20% reported delayed-onset PTSD. Also, significant cases of individuals experienced traumatic mental disorders. The analysis showed that 24% of the respondents were diagnosed with PTSD at the initial screening but recovered, while 42% had no
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
X. Hu et al.
Probable post-traumatic stress disorder and its predictors in disaster-bereaved survivors: a longitudinal study after the sichuan earthquake
Arch. Psychiatr. Nurs. (2016)
B. Han et al.
Validation of a brief PTSD screener for underserved patients in federally qualified health centers
Gen. Hosp. Psychiatr. (2016)
A.J. Lang et al.
An abbreviated PTSD checklist for use as a screening instrument in primary care
Behav. Res. Ther. (2005)
Z. Meng et al.
Post-traumatic stress disorder and post-traumatic growth among the adult survivors of the Lushan earthquake: selecting resilience as the moderator
Int. J. Disaster Risk Reduc. (2018)
S.E.K. Henderson et al.
Predictors of trauma and distress in Sri Lanka five years after the Indian Ocean tsunami: a cross-sectional study
Int. J. Disaster Risk Reduc. (2015)
Y. Yang et al.
The contributing factors of delayed-onset post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms: a nested case-control study conducted after the 2008 wenchuan earthquake
Front. Public Health (2021)
S. Eray et al.
The effects of relocation and social support on long-term outcomes of adolescents following a major earthquake: a controlled study from Turkey
Int. J. Disaster Risk Reduc. (2017)
F. Lavigne et al.
The 2004 indien ocean tsunami World Health Organization
Regional Office for South-East Asia (2013)
A. Suppasri et al.
A decade after the 2004 Indian ocean tsunami: the progress in disaster preparedness and future challenges in Indonesia, Sri Lanka, Thailand and the Maldives
Pure Appl. Geophys. (2015)
Efektivitas penyaluran bantuan kemanusiaan bagi korban bencana pasca tsunami di Banda Aceh
J Kebijak dan Adm Publik (2008)
Unearthing the most vulnerable: pychological impact of natural disasters
Eur. J. Psychiatr. (2007)
F. Van Griensven et al.
Mental health problems among adults in tsunami-affected areas in southern Thailand
J. Am. Med. Assoc. (2006)
N. Kar et al.
Long-term mental health outcomes following the 2004 Asian tsunami disaster
Disaster Health (2014)
G.A. Fernando et al.
Growing pains: the impact of disaster-related and daily stressors on the psychological and psychosocial functioning of youth in Sri Lanka
Child Dev. (2010)
A. Ikeda et al.
Longitudinal effects of disaster-related experiences on mental health among Fukushima nuclear plant workers: the Fukushima NEWS Project Study
Psychol. Med. (2017)
P.G. Van Der Velden et al.
Persistent mental health disturbances during the 10 years after a disaster: four-wave longitudinal comparative study
Psychiatr. Clin. Neurosci. (2013)
C.A. Fernandez et al.
Longitudinal course of disaster-related PTSD among a prospective sample of adult Chilean natural disaster survivors
Int. J. Epidemiol. (2017)
R.E. Adams et al.
Predictors of PTSD and delayed PTSD after disaster: the impact of exposure and psychosocial resources
J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. (2006)
G.E. Smid et al.
Late-onset posttraumatic stress disorder following a disaster: a longitudinal study
Psychol Trauma Theory, Res Pract Policy (2012)
M.E. Kronenberg et al.
Children of Katrina: lessons learned about postdisaster symptoms and recovery patterns
Child Dev. (2010)
A.S. Masten et al.
Disaster preparation and recovery: lessons from research on resilience in human development
Ecol. Soc. (2008)
There are more references available in the full text version of this article.